Episode 36 — War with the Franks — transcript

Painting from the 1490s of a religious procession in Piazza San Marco, with the words Venetian Stories across

Written by

on

Transcript

The war with the Franks in 809 was one of the most decisive events in the millennial history of Venice, and the consequences can be discerned for centuries to come, and in some cases until the end of the republic in 1797, almost a thousand years later.

Internal division in Venetia

In the last few episodes, we’ve seen how Venetian society was ridden by internal divisions, which often deteriorated into physical violence, mutilations and killings.

Most of the early dukes of Venetia were violently deposed, blinded and sometimes killed.

With the appointment in 764 of Mauricius, the violence subsided. Mauricius succeeded in keeping the internal discords under control, while he shepherded Venetia through the period of the Carolingian conquest of the Kingdom of the Lombards, in and after 774.

His son Giovanni became his co-ruler, and when Mauricius died in 787, Giovanni ruled alone. Later, he appointed his son Mauricius co-ruler.

Giovanni clearly didn’t command the same respect as his father, and the old factionalism reared its head again.

The three generations of this dynasty of dukes, Mauricius, Giovanni and Mauricius the second, were from Heraclia, and in favour of a close relationship to Constantinople.

Another Giovanni was the patriarch of Grado since 766. He was from Trieste, which had become first Lombard, then Frankish, and he favoured of a close relationship with the Franks.

The patriarch wasn’t alone. A large part of the Venetian elite, especially around the cities of Metamauco and Equilo, supported the same pro-Frankish line.

In 802, something — and we don’t know what — brought this conflict to a head. Duke Giovanni sent his son Mauricius to Grado — with a fleet of warships — and they attacked and took the city. The elderly patriarch Giovanni was captured, hauled up a tall tower, and thrown down to his death.

Despite this show of force and determination on behalf of the dukes, the canons of the cathedral of Grado chose a new patriarch of the same political orientation, and also a relative of slain patriarch.

Patriarch Fortunatus therefore promptly fled the duchy, and went to Treviso on the mainland, in Frankish territory.

Here, he gathered a group of Venetians of the pro-Frankish faction around him. The following year, Fortunatus went to Bavaria to meet Charlemagne, and the others descended on the duchy.

The dukes Giovanni and Mauricius were probably captured, and sent as prisoners to the Franks, and they never returned to Venetia again.

Obelerius, a native of Metamauco and the leader of the group around Fortunatus, was appointed duke, and he immediately made his brother Beatus co-ruler.

Consequently, by 804, the pro-Frankish faction was firmly in control of the duchy, and the pro-Byzantine faction was left leaderless.

Heraclia — the main city of the pro-Byzantine faction — was destroyed and burned, and the new dukes sent a fleet to raid the Dalmatian coast, which was Byzantine territory.

Many wealthy families from Heraclia moved to Rivoalto, and some of our sources contain long lists of such families.

A tale of two empires

The conflict between Byzantine and Frankish aligned factions was not something specific to Venetia.

Constantinople hadn’t forgotten the Exarchate, and still held large parts of Southern Italy. They still wanted to play a role in Northern Italy, despite the earlier setbacks.

When the imperial ambitions of Charlemagne arrived in Italy, the two empires started rubbing up against each other. With the conquest of Istria, which had been Byzantine until around 770, they were bordering directly on each other, and soon Charlemagne cast his eyes on Dalmatia, a Byzantine province in the Balkans.

In 787, Constantinople tried an offensive from Southern Italy, maybe hoping to get the Lombard dukes of Benevento and Spoleto on side against the Franks, but it failed miserably.

This might be the reason for the expulsion of the Venetians — with the confiscation of all goods and properties — from all the lands of the former Exarchate in 787 or shortly thereafter. This is revealed by a papal letter from Adrian I to Charlemagne, where he confirmed that he had ordered the archbishop of Ravenna to do as Charlemagne had requested.

We have no sources indicating a direct conflict between Venetia and the Franks at the time, so the expulsion was probably a part of the wider Byzantine-Frankish conflict.

Evidently, both pope Adrian and Charlemagne saw Venetia as a Byzantine province, and therefore a legitimate target in the conflict.

Despite several attempts at establishing some kind of coexistence between the two empires, the relationship remained fraught, and much more so after Christmas of the year 800, when Charlemagne had the pope crown him Roman Emperor.

This was totally unacceptable to Constantinople, which saw itself as the Roman Empire since Odoacer had sent the imperial regalia of the Western Empire to Constantinople in 476. The claim of Charlemagne was a stab at the very heart of Byzantine identity.

The situation after 800 was therefore of tension and conflict between the two main empires of Europe, which naturally centred on their shared borderlands, around the upper Adriatic Sea. On the Byzantine side of that border were the provinces of Venetia and Dalmatia.

The events, which played out in Venetia in this period, must therefore be seen in the light of the wider Byzantine-Frankish conflict, and not as something local and specific to Venetia.

Sources

We do, however, have a problem. The sources we have — and we do have sources from all sides of the conflict — offer no simple, or even coherent, narrative for how this conflict played out in Venetia.

The oldest source is the Annales Regni Francorum — the Annals of the Kingdom of the Franks — which are almost contemporary with the events.

As the name implies, they were written year by year, at the court of Charlemagne and Louis the Pious, covering the period from 741 to 829. Each year, the main events of the past year were added to the list.

The Annales therefore don’t have a single author, but were rather a product of the imperial chancery, which followed the court around the empire.

The Duchy of the Venetians appear in the Annales for the years 806, 807 and 809–811, after which the Carolingian court clearly lost interest in the duchy.

Needless to say, the Annales offer a narrative which was entirely from the point of view of the imperial Frankish court, and most blame for the conflict was assigned to the Venetian dukes.

Also from the Frankish side, we have a couple of letters from Charlemagne to two successive Byzantine emperors, as the two empires agreed on the terms of the peace.

We also have a Byzantine source, which, however, is more than a century later, written by an emperor.

Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus ruled from 913 to 959, being crowned as a child. In his later years, around 950, he wrote a manual for governing the empire for his son, called the De Administrando Imperio — on the administration of the empire.

In this manual, there are two chapters mentioning the Venetians. Most of it is geography, and about how the Venetians came to live in the lagoons. The only major event recounted in any detail, is the war with the Franks in 809.

Constantine VII lived in the imperial palace in Constantinople, and probably never left the city in his lifetime. We don’t know where he got his information from, but at his time, there was a solid Venetian presence in Constantinople. There were many merchants and sailors in the city, and also official emissaries and ambassadors, as Constantinople was important to the Venetians.

The first Venetian source is — surprise — John the Deacon, writing around the year 1000 in the palace of the doges in Rivoalto.

John the Deacon clearly knew the Annales, but used them very selectively. He diminished as much as possible any outside influences on what happened in Venetia, and placed all blame for the war squarely on the Franks.

It is still a plausible and fairly coherent narrative.

Not so much for the next source, in chronological order.

The Chronicon Altinate survives in manuscripts from the 1200s. It is a collection of varioius texts, several of which are generally believed to be from the 1100s or even the late 1000s. The last text, book VIII, is almost entirely about this war, but it is different from all the previous sources.

It is … it is bonkers.

The chronology is totally broken, and persons and events appear across time and out of order. The entire narrative is anything but plausible and coherent.

It is full of tiny details and long quotes, written three or four centuries after the events, but nowhere to be found in the earlier sources.

It comes across as the kind of narrative, you get of distant historical events, which has been thoroughly mythologised and mixed up with other related or unrelated events, told and retold, while changing along the way, to an extent where what actually happened becomes secondary to what people thought had happened, or what they wanted to believe had happened.

The whole thing reads like a folktale, not with a witch doing magic, but with a wise old woman tricking the Franks into humiliating defeat.

The account of the Chronicon Altinate is not as much a source for the events of 809, as for what people made of the war several centuries later.

The reason why I bring it up here, is that bits and pieces of this bungled and impossible narrative shows up in most of the later chronicles and writings, somewhat sanitised to make it more plausible.

The Les estoires de Venise, written in early French by Martino da Canal around 1270, contains a sanitised version of the war from the Chronicon Altinate, and in the Chronica per extensum descripta, from the 1340s by doge Andrea Dandolo, we find the old woman tricking the Franks.

Even in modern scholarly works, these colourful bits sometimes reappear.

The Annales Regni Francorum

The relevant parts of the Annales Regni Francorum are not very long, so here they are.

For 806:

Shortly after the Lord’s birth, Willerius and Beatus, dukes of Venetia, as well as Paulus, duke of Zara, and Donatus, bishop of the same city, ambassadors of the Dalmatians, came before the emperor with large gifts. And there was a settlement by the emperor concerning the dukes and peoples of both Venetia and Dalmatia.

The dukes were Obelerius and Beatus, but the scribes of the Annales got the name Obelerius wrong consistently.

The essence of the entry is simple. The two Byzantine duchies submitted voluntarily to Charlemagne, offering gifts, as it was proper for a vassal approaching his lord.

We don’t know what the settlement was, but it would have the decisions and charters necessary to incorporate the two duchies into the Carolingian Empire.

In short, Venetia moved into the Frankish sphere of influence, which was a choice perfectly in line with the intentions of the patriarch Fortunatus and the dukes Obelerius and Beatus.

For the following year, 807, we have:

The patrician Nicetas, who was in Venetia with a fleet from Constantinople, made peace with King Pepin and established a truce until the month of August, and after having completed his duty, he returned to Constantinople.

The Byzantine Empire had to react. They sent a navy to the area, commanded by a high-ranking court official — a patrician — to re-assert their dominance over the province of Venetia, and obtain the recognition of that control from the Franks, which they did.

Here, with the swift Byzantine intervention, Venetia was brought back into the sphere of influence of the eastern empire.

Two years later, in 809, the Byzantines are back.

A fleet sent from Constantinople first reached Dalmatia, then landed in Venetia; and while it was wintering there, part of it approached the island of Comacchio, and having engaged in battle against the garrison stationed there, having been defeated by them and forced to flee, it returned to Venetia.

However, the commander of the fleet, named Paulus, as if it was his duty to arrange peace between the Franks and the Greeks, tried to negotiate with King Pepin of Italy, but with Wilharenus and Beatus, the dukes of Venetia, obstructing all his attempts and even plotting against him, he left when he discovered their treachery.

Constantinople was back to assert control over Venetia, and this time the navy stayed for longer, over the winter.

Comacchio was a trading city like Heraclia, Metamauco and Rivoalto, situated in a lagoon south of the estuary of the Po river. It was for much of the early Middle Ages an important competitor to Venetia, and the attack was likely both a show of force, and to favour Venetian trade.

Again, like with the first naval visit to Venetia, the commander tried to negotiate a stable peace between the two powers.

The failure of the peace negotiations are explicitly placed on the dukes of Venetia — the scribe getting the name of Obelerius wrong again — who are accused of treachery.

The dukes are essentially depicted as weather wanes. First they declared their allegiance to the Franks, but when the Byzantines show up with a navy, they immediately switched sides, but didn’t even do that honestly.

Following year, 810, has two entries related to Venetia.

Meanwhile, King Pepin, angered by the treachery of the Venetian dukes, ordered Venetia to be attacked by land and sea; having subdued Venetia and received the submission of its dukes, he sent the same fleet to devastate the coasts of Dalmatia. But when Paulus, the prefect of Cephalonia, arrived with the eastern fleet to bring help to the Dalmatians, the royal fleet returned to its own ports.

The reaction of the Franks was targeted at Venetia and Dalmatia, both of which had declared their allegiance to Charlemagne four years earlier, only to turn back to Constantinople, when the eastern empire appeared to be the stronger.

Here, king Pepin of Italy attacked, defeated and subdued Venetia, then tried to do the same with Dalmatia, but retreated when the Byzantines showed up there.

This paragraph is the entire account of war between Venetia and the Franks. It clearly wasn’t as monumental an event for the Franks as it later became for the Venetians.

In the Annales, the Venetians were squarely defeated.

While this might have been a Frankish lie to keep up the imperial façade, there is little reason to believe so, as the same paragraph readily admitted defeat to the Byzantines in Dalmatia.

The second entry for 810 is the peace settlement.

Coming from Aachen in the month of October, the emperor heard the mentioned embassies and made peace with Emperor Nicephorus and with King Abdul Aziz of Spain. For he returned Venetia to Nicephorus and received back Count Haimric, who had formerly been captured by the Saracens, with Abdul Aziz releasing him.

This is the peace settlement, which the two empires had been trying to reach for years.

The Annales omitted the death of Pepin in 810 in Milan, and as his son and heir was an infant, Charlemagne himself picked up the reins in the Kingdom of Italy.

Charlemagne handed back Venetia to Byzantium, so the message of the Annales was that Venetia was under Frankish control, and that it was Charlemagne’s to give away.

The counterpart mentioned here was from the Muslim emirate of al-Andalus in Spain, not from Byzantium.

Finally, for 811, we have:

After Arsafius, spatharios — this was the name of the envoy of Emperor Nicephorus — was dismissed, envoys were sent to Constantinople by the emperor to confirm the peace. Bishop Haido of Basel, Count Hugo of Thuringia, and Aio the Lombard from Forum Julii, along with a certain Leo spatharios, a Sicilian by birth, and Willeri, duke of the Venetians. One of them had fled the emperor from Sicily ten years earlier while in Rome, and was sent back when he wanted to return home; the other was stripped of his honour because of treachery, and ordered to return to his lord in Constantinople.

The peace treaty was finalised by envoys travelling back and forth between the two imperial courts.

Duke Obelerius — again mis-named — had been deposed due to his treachery and was sent to Constantinople.

Just like Venetia had been under Frankish control, and therefore could be handed over, so duke Obelerius was a captive of the Franks, and could be handed over.

In this narrative, Obelerius had betrayed both empires. He had tried to serve two masters, but had been loyal to none of them.

All in all, the account of the Annales Regni Francorum is straightforward, and fairly plausible. There are no blatant inconsistencies or evident falsehoods.

The conflict was between the two empires. Venetia and Dalmatia were simply the battlefields the empires fought on and over.

At the end of the conflict, other things mattered more to Charlemagne than keeping Venetia under his control, and he traded the province for something else, but the Frankish annals don’t say what.

Constantine VII

Now, let’s turn to the Byzantine side, and see what emperor Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus wrote about this conflict.

The text is not very long, only four paragraphs, so we can take that in its entirety too.

This is a translation by R. J. H. Jenkins, published by the Dumbarton Oaks Center for Byzantine Studies in 1967.

But again, many years after the withdrawal of Attila, king Pippin arrived, who at that time was ruling over Papia and other kingdoms. For this Pippin had three brothers, and they were ruling over all the Frank and Slavonic regions. Now when king Pippin came against the Venetians with power and a large army, he blockaded them along the mainland, on the far side of the crossing between it and the islands of Venice, at a place called Aeibolas.

Constantine attributed the settlement of the Venetians in the lagoons to the invasion of Attila the Hun in 410, and not to the invasion of the Lombards in 568–569, hence the initial reference to Attila.

Constantine had rather vague ideas about the Franks and the Carolingian Empire, and also about the geography of the Venetians lagoons.

Papia is Pavia, the capital of the Kingdom of the Lombards, and later of the Frankish Kingdom of Italy. The “Frank and Slavonic regions” were the territories of the Carolingian Empire at the time of Charlemagne, but it had broken up in several distinct parts at the time of Constantine.

The locality of Aeibolas was likely Albiola, which was a settlement at the southern end of the Lido di Venezia, at or near the current Alberoni, where one of the main passages between the Adriatic and the lagoon is situated.

Well, when the Venetians saw king Pippin coming against them with his power and preparing to take ship with the horses to the island of Madamaucon (for this is an island near the mainland), they laid down spars and fenced off the whole crossing. The army of king Pippin, being brought to a stand (for it was not possible for them to cross at any other point), blockaded them along the mainland six months, fighting with them daily.

Metamauco, not distant from Albiola, was the capital of the Duchy of the Venetians at the time, and therefore the primary target of the Frankish army.

The Venetians would man their ships and take up position behind the spars they had laid down, and king Pippin would take up position with his army along the shore. The Venetians assailed them with arrows and javelins, and stopped them from crossing over to the island. So then king Pippin, at a loss, said to the Venetians: «You are beneath my hand and my providence, since you are of my country and domain.» But the Venetians answered him: «We want to be servants of the emperor of the Romans, and not of you.»

When, however, they had for long been straitened by the trouble that had come upon them, the Venetians made a treaty of peace with king Pippin, agreeing to pay him a very considerable tribute. But since that time the tribute has gone on diminishing year by year, though it is paid even to this day. For the Venetians pay to him who rules over the kingdom of Italy, that is, Papia, a twopenny fee of 36 pounds of uncoined silver annually.

What Constantine recounted here was essentially a draw, a stalemate. None of the two parties could get the upper hand, so they agreed to call it off in a way that wasn’t too dishonourable for either of them.

There’s nothing in this account of a wider Byzantine-Frankish conflict, or of any Byzantine involvement at all. The Venetians fought alone.

Likewise, there is nothing about the internal affairs of the duchy.

In a way, this narrative heralds some elements in the later Venetian storyline, of the independent minded Venetians fighting courageously and refusing to submit to the Franks.

The Istoria Veneticorum

The Istoria Veneticorum by John the Deacon has many more entries for the dukes Obelerius and Beatus than for their predecessors, so I won’t bother you with the entire text.

My translation of all the entries for the two dukes is linked from the show notes.

The patriarch Fortunatus, who had succeeded the murdered patriarch Giovanni in 802, had fled Venetia, but came back sometimes after Obelerius and Beatus were appointed dukes, but he soon had to flee again.

And because he greatly feared the arrival of the patrician Nicetas, who at that time was sent by the emperor with an army to the regions of Dalmatia and Venetia, he left his seat and his own city and returned again to Francia.

It looks like John the Deacon had read the Frankish annals, but he conveniently omitted the journey of Obelerius and Beatus to submit to Charlemagne, so the Byzantine navy under Nicetas appeared out of nowhere in his narrative.

Indeed, duke Obelerius received the title of spatharios through the patrician Nicetas. Beatus, his brother, however, went to Constantinople with the aforementioned Nicetas, bringing with him the hostages of the Venetians …

The title of spatharios ranked higher than hypatos, which was usually bestowed on the dukes of the Venetians, but the Venetians still had to offer hostages, including the younger of the two dukes.

Then duke Beatus, who went to Constantinople with the patrician Nicetas, having returned to Venetia, was honoured by the emperor with the rank of hypatus.

At this point, Constantinople appeared to be satisfied that Venetia was indeed a loyal province, and that the dukes were aligned with the empire.

John the Deacon generally tried to write Byzantium out of the history of the Venetians, but here he cannot remove them entirely.

Meanwhile, the treaty that the Venetian people once had with the Italian king was broken at that time under King Pepin, who then sent a huge army of Lombards to capture the Venetian province.

After struggling greatly through the passages that separate the islands of the coast, they finally reached a place called Albiola.

They could make no further progress, and there the dukes with a large Venetian force, boldly attacked the king, and by divine intervention the Venetians were granted triumph over their enemies, so the aforementioned king withdrew humiliated.

Thus, in the year of the incarnation of our Redeemer […] King Pepin died, and the envoys from Constantinople who had been coming to him to negotiate, returned.

Having omitted the submission of the dukes to Charlemagne, John the Deacon can pass the blame for the war to the Franks, who in his narrative, gratuitously broke a treaty in an unprovoked attack.

The story line of the fighting is not substantially different from Constantine VII, except that in this narrative, the Venetians defeated the Franks outright in a bold attack.

It was still, however, the Byzantines who came to negotiate a peace.

At that time, an envoy from Constantinople, named Arsafius, visited Venetia and through the consent and support of the Venetians, obtained that both dukes lost their dignity and their homeland; one, that is Obelerius, sought Constantinople, while the other went to Zara. They governed the duchy of the Venetians for a period of five years.

Then, when it had been […] years since the incarnation of the Lord, the Venetians, by common decree, preferred the seat of the duchy to be on the island of Rivoalto, and elevated to this honour a certain man, named Agnellus, who constructed the palace which still stands today.

In the Annales, the Franks deposed duke Obelerius and sent him to Constantinople, but in the version of John the Deacon, where Venetia was never defeated by the Franks, it was the Byzantine envoy who deposed the dukes, but explicitly with the consent of the Venetians.

Likewise, John the Deacon described the move of the seat of the duchy to Rivoalto as a free choice — a preference — and not at all because the old palace in Metamauco had been sacked and destroyed by the Franks.

Constantine VII also had a note about the capital.

The first doge among them had been appointed before king Pippin came against them. At that time the doge’s residence was at a place called Civitanova, which means ‘new city’. But because this island aforesaid is close to the mainland, by common consent they moved the doge’s residence to another island, where it now is at this present, because it is at a distance from the mainland, as far off as one may see a man on horseback.

What happened

We have three different accounts of the conflict, from three different perspectives, and with three different outcomes.

The classical narrative of this war is that of John the Deacon, often with some embellishments drawn from the Chronicon Altinate, as in the Chronica extensa by Andrea Dandolo.

To a large extent, it comes down to the large influence the Chronica extensa had on most of the later Venetian historiography.

The story is simple and compelling. The vicious Franks attacked plucky little Venetia, which courageously fought back and won. David against Goliath.

It can still be found, even in recent publications, but is it true?

The main problem is that the Annales Regni Francorum offer a much simpler, a more coherent and a far more plausible narrative.

The credibility of the Annales is increased by it admitting defeat to the Byzantines in Dalmatia. Why should the scribes at the Frankish court lie about defeat in Venetia, while admitting it in Dalmatia?

Furthermore, the Annales are almost contemporary to the events, while John the Deacon wrote two centuries later.

At his time, the events had already become half-way mythological — at least in Venetian circles, which is very much where John the Deacon was.

The elements of open defiance to the Franks in the account of Porphyrogenitus already showed such signs myth-building, assuming his sources were at least in part Venetian, which is very likely.

It is not impossible for an underdog to win a fight against a much larger and stronger power — it does happen occasionally — but usually, it doesn’t.

A plausible scenario

A plausible scenario is therefore of the back and forth in a conflict between two empires, with Venetia sitting in the middle, trying to survive the best it can, being more object of the conflict than participant in it.

The waves of the wider conflict rebounded within Venetian society as a factional divide, between those who wanted Venetia to be on the Byzantine side, and those who favoured the Franks.

When the Frankish faction got the upper hand after the murder of the patriarch, they tried to bring Venetia into the Frankish orbit. Obelerius and Beatus travelled with representatives of Dalmatia to the Frankish court to swear fealty to Charlemagne.

Byzantium reacted by sending a navy under the patrician Nicetas to the upper Adriatic, to re-assert power over the two provinces. In Venetia, Obelerius and Beatus promptly changed sides, accepted Byzantine titles and therefore Byzantine lordship over Venetia, and supplied hostages as proof of good faith.

Pepin, king of Italy and son of Charlemagne, consequently attacked to restore the two provinces to the Carolingian Empire. He took Venetia, causing the two dukes to switch sides once again.

Continuing by sea, Pepin met a second Byzantine navy, commanded by Paulus, in Dalmatia, and retreated.

Shortly afterwards, he was in Milan, fatally sick.

The Byzantine navy continued to Venetia, where the two dukes were deposed and replaced by Agnello Partecipazio from the pro-Byzantine faction.

The Byzantine fleet, returning towards Constantinople, took Obelerius along, where he remained for two decades, and left Beatus in Zara in Dalmatia.

The change of capital

The seat of the duchy was moved from Metamauco to Rivoalto.

The ducal palace at Metamauco was possibly destroyed during the fighting, but it was also where Obelerius, Beatus and most of the pro-Frankish faction in Venetia came from.

The centre of the pro-Byzantine faction had been in Heraclia, but that city had been destroyed once, or maybe twice, during the short reign of Obelerius and Beatus, possibly as an act of revenge over the previous dukes. Later chronicles ascribe the destruction of Heraclia to king Pepin, but there’s no trace of that in the earlier sources.

Numerous leading families from Heraclia, and from the nearby Equilo, uprooted and resettled in Rivoalto. The Chronicon Altinate has long lists of these families, connecting them to the dominant Venetian families of the 1100s.

The new duke was from one such family.

The change of seat of government therefore also reflected a change of governing faction within the duchy, Rivoalto effectively being the successor and heir to Heraclia.

Rivoalto — which is now Rialto — didn’t mean just the limited area which we now call Rialto, around the marketplace and the bridge. Back then, the name was also used for the wider, surrounding marsh area, that is, much of what is now the city of Venice.

The place in Rivoalto, where Agnello Partecipazio set up the new seat of government, was a bit of uninhabited marsh near the start of the Grand Canal, with a clear line of view to the south, towards ancient Metamauco.

It is where the Doge’s palace stands today.

The peace

The conflict between Constantinople and Charlemagne ended with a peace treaty, which was negotiated over a period of several years.

It was negotiated between Constantinople and Charlemagne, without any participation of the Venetians. This too, underlines that Venetia was one of the objects of the war, not one of the participants, something the later Venetian sources tried hard to tone down.

The Annales Regni Francorum noted that the patrician Nicetas made a truce with Pepin in 807, but it evidently didn’t hold. Likewise, Paulus, the commander of the second Byzantine fleet, tried to negotiate a peace in 809, but that attempt failed too.

The two parties only reached an agreement after the failed campaign of Pepin against Venetia and Dalmatia, and his subsequent death, which left Charlemagne himself in charge of the negotiations.

We know a bit more about the negotiations thanks to two letters Charlemagne wrote to Nicephorus in 811 and to his successor Michael in 813.

The letters are beautifully translated and commented by historian Sam Ottewill-Soulsby, with links in the show-notes.

Venetia is not mentioned in the letters at all, not even indirectly.

The envoy of emperor Nicephorus was a spatharios named Arsafius.

Nicephorus had sent Arsafius to negotiate with Pepin, but the king died before the envoy arrived, and Arsafius was redirected to Charlemagne himself.

From the first letter we have:

… we have kindly and with honour received into Our court your envoy, Our brother, whom you sent to our son, King Pippin of good memory, namely Arsafius, the famous imperial spatharios, along with the words and letters of your affection. And although he had not been sent to us, we have taken care of him as if he was sent to us, and we listened to him and, because we thought it prudent, talked with him about what he brought.

Charlemagne accepted the envoy, even if he wasn’t meant for himself, and he was very pleased with Arsafius, with whom he agreed a peace treaty.

Arsafius brought this document, with all the proper seals and signatures, to Constantinople, but emperor Nicephorus probably never saw it, as he was killed in a war with the Bulgars.

The next letter is for his successor Michael I, and it reiterated the need for a proper ratification of the treaty, which among other things meant a copy in Greek with all the seals and signatures to be sent to Charlemagne.

The salutation of this letter gives us a hint at what Charlemagne was interested in from the peace deal.

In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Charles, by the largess of divine grace, Emperor and Augustus, and also King of the Franks and of the Lombards, wishes his esteemed and venerable brother Michael, the glorious Emperor and Augustus, eternity with our Lord Jesus Christ.

Charlemagne wanted Byzantium to recognise his title as Roman emperor.

He styled himself “Emperor and Augustus”, and he styled Michael “Emperor and Augustus”.

He also called Michael “brother”.

The wish of Charlemagne was for himself and the Byzantine emperor to be peers, to be of equal rank.

In the end, Constantinople conceded him the title “Emperor”, but not “Roman Emperor”.

Charlemagne, on the other hand, promised to leave the Byzantine provinces of Venetia and Dalmatia in peace, and so he did.

So did also his successors for a long time to come.

We don’t have the full text of this treaty, which is sometimes called the “Treaty of Aachen” and sometimes the “Peace of Nicephorus”. We only have bits and pieces quoted elsewhere, but it is enough to get a broad idea of the exchange.

The outcome for Venetia

Despite the likely minimal role Venetia had in the conflict, the outcome was highly significant for the duchy.

This conflict and the subsequent peace meant that Venetia definitively remained Byzantine, as the only territory of the former Exarchate of Ravenna. Venetia remained eastern, in a northern Italy, which became firmly western, through the dominance of the Carolingian, and later Holy Roman Empire.

Some elements of this eastern-ness persisted for a thousand years, such as the official dress of state officials.

There was lots of internal strife in Venice in the centuries to come, but nothing comparable to the divide between the Frankish and the Byzantine factions, which saw assassinations and the destruction of entire cities. Through the terseness of our sources, there are shadows of civil war and violent reprisals.

Being a part of the sphere of influence of Constantinople, while also being geographically in the west, was foundational for the later mercantile developments of Venice, and therefore of the wealth and power the republic acquired in the centuries following these events.

Finally, the destruction and abandonment of the ancient cities of Heraclia, Metamauco and Equilo, together with the establishment of the seat of government in Rivoalto, made Rivoalto — future city of Venice — the uncontested centre of the Duchy of the Venetians, politically, economically and religiously.